Skip to content

Roundtable: The race to 1677

Once a bustling Victorian railway goods shed, the building now home to Sunderland’s Housing Innovation and Construction Skills Academy (HICSA) has swapped moving goods for the development of the next generation of construction talent.

Set within the Riverside Sunderland regeneration scheme, the base symbolises the region’s changing industrial landscape, where the heritage of the past is helping shape the opportunities of the future. Yet, as major regeneration and infrastructure projects gather pace across the North East, a significant challenge remains: ensuring thousands of young people training for construction careers gain the practical experience, industry connections and confidence needed to turn classroom learning into lasting employment.

Against this backdrop, senior figures from industry, education and regional organisations gathered at HICSA for a roundtable hosted by N magazine publisher NET alongside the North East Construction Technical Excellence College (CTEC), Education Partnership North East and RE:GEN Group.

The discussion explored the barriers and opportunities surrounding a new Department for Education initiative requiring further education construction learners to complete at least three weeks of meaningful industry experience, and how greater collaboration could help deliver North East CTEC’s target of filling 1677 placements.

Words by Peter Anderson
Photography by Elliot Nichol

This roundtable forms part of a wider built environment series, which began in the summer at Northumbria University. The series has brought together further and higher education, industry operators and bodies including the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority to create a blueprint capable of driving a step-change in talent development and building a skills ecosystem that meets future industry needs. Further details on future events will be unveiled in the coming weeks. Contact NET partnerships and marketing managers Sarah Law ([email protected]) and Charlie Sander ([email protected]) for more information.

What are the biggest barriers preventing the North East from delivering more meaningful industry placements?

The scale of the North East’s construction skills shortage is considerable.

According to the Construction Industry Training Board’s Construction Workforce Outlook 2025–2029, the region needs to recruit an additional 1390 workers annually to meet demand, placing further pressure on a sector already contending with an ageing workforce and recruitment difficulties.

The new industry placement initiative offers an opportunity to strengthen the connection between education and employment, helping young people gain practical experience while allowing businesses to nurture future talent.

Yet securing 1677 placements across a sector dominated by small and micro-businesses presents significant obstacles.

From supervision costs and health and safety requirements to uncertain project pipelines and fragmented relationships between employers and education providers, roundtable members examined what prevents more businesses from opening their doors to young people.

For Rebecca Storey, regional construction skills director at North East CTEC, the disconnect between students studying construction and those entering the workforce is particularly concerning.

She said: “We are training thousands of students each year, and very few of them then transition into the workforce.

“I see that as a huge missed opportunity when we have a sector that is crying out for new staff.

“Industry placements could act as a valuable bridge, giving young people workplace exposure, helping them make informed career decisions and developing the work-readiness skills employers are looking for.”

However, Rebecca acknowledged smaller firms often lack the resources and certainty enjoyed by larger contractors, thus making it difficult to commit to placements.

She added: “We need to give smaller businesses more confidence to invest and support industry placements.

“We are training thousands of students each year, and very few of them then transition into the workforce – I see that as a huge missed opportunity”
Rebecca Storey, regional construction skills director, North East CTEC

“Projects get delayed and circumstances change, which makes it difficult for them to plan ahead.

“We need to look at how we can bring those businesses along with us and give them the support they need.”

The concern was echoed by Catriona Lingwood, chief executive of Constructing Excellence North East, who emphasised the limited capacity of smaller businesses to offer placements.

She said: “The barrier we’ve got is that 91 per cent of the industry is made up of small and medium-sized enterprises.

“Some of these businesses simply cannot take on a work placement student because they don’t have the capacity.

“Throwing money at it isn’t necessarily going to work.

“We need to think about what support we can offer these smaller businesses to make placements possible.”

The practical difficulties were underlined by Darush Dodds, director of corporate affairs and social value at Bowburn-headquartered Esh Group, which employs 72 apprentices and delivers more than 1000 days of placements annually across the North East, Tees Valley and Yorkshire.

Despite operating across approximately 100 live sites, Darush explained that accommodating learners requires careful planning, training and supervision.

He said: “There is a capacity issue.

“We have to consider insurance, health and safety requirements, and the training a learner needs before coming into our workplace.

N magazine editor Steven Hugill, far left, chairs the roundtable discussion

“It’s not like sitting at a desk in an office – you’re entering one of the most dangerous working environments there is.

“Mentoring is another important consideration.

“We have 40 mentors, but without good mentoring, placements simply won’t deliver what we want them to.”

For Rachel Cox, director of property repairs at Seaham-headquartered believe housing, another obstacle is the absence of a structured system connecting education providers with employers.

Although the housing association offers work experience, she acknowledged arrangements can be reactive, with insufficient communication about learners and their needs.

She said: “It’s very much a case of somebody coming to us and saying they’ve got a person who needs work experience, and we’re saying, ‘Right, okay’.

“But that collaborative approach, understanding the learner, their journey and what the provider wants, isn’t always happening.

“I think a regional approach, where we understand what different organisations can offer and how we can work together, would make a real difference.”

The need for greater coordination was reinforced by Dr Susan Dawson, associate professor and educational partnerships lead at Northumbria University’s School of Architecture and Built Environment, who suggested the difficulties extend beyond placement availability.

She said: “The education system, whether that is schools, further education or higher education, can be difficult for employers to navigate.

“Education providers and businesses often speak different languages, making it harder to understand each other’s needs and work together effectively.

“We need a much more joined-up approach.

“It’s not simply about encouraging collaboration; it’s about investing in those relationships, changing how we work and making sure education and industry are working towards the same goals.

“We have to move beyond simply talking about skills shortages and create a system that delivers the right people for the opportunities available.”

How can education providers and employers work together to create placements that deliver lasting value?

Securing enough placements is only part of the equation.

With learners expected to complete at least 15 days of industry experience, the emphasis must be on quality as well as quantity, ensuring time with employers builds the skills, confidence and knowledge needed to progress into apprenticeships and employment.

That demands closer collaboration between colleges and businesses, from preparing students for working life to matching them with opportunities reflecting their interests and abilities.

With careers across the built environment extending beyond traditional trades to include design, surveying, planning and project management, roundtable members explored how sustained partnerships, mentoring and exposure to different roles can turn short-term placements into lasting opportunities.

There was broad agreement that building relationships over time, rather than relying on one-off arrangements, was fundamental to that ambition.

Alan Goundry, director of technical education at East Durham College, pointed to an example delivering results through the college’s Developing Futures partnership with housebuilder Robertson Homes and its supply chain.

Combining curriculum development, masterclasses, site visits and interview preparation with practical experience, the programme provides a structured route towards apprenticeships and employment.

“The Gentogether partnership means we know we’ll still be delivering kitchens and bathrooms in Sunderland in nine years’ time – that gives us the opportunity to understand our commitments, identify skills gaps and work with colleges to address them”
Tom Lamb, chief strategy officer, RE:GEN Group

Alan said: “It’s a structured programme where the supply chain gets time with learners throughout their journey.

“It starts with employers helping us shape the curriculum, making sure we’re delivering the right skills.

“The employers get to know the learners, understand their abilities and identify the people they want to take on.

“The majority of those placements turn into apprenticeships because employers have been involved from the start and can see who’s right for them.”

The value of sustained engagement was reinforced by Ashleigh Coombes, social value manager at family-owned construction and property maintenance company Wates Group, which has a regional office in Sunderland.

The company is the main contractor on the multi-million-pound Envision AESC UK electric vehicle battery gigafactory at the International Advanced Manufacturing Park that straddles Sunderland and South Tyneside.

Ashleigh explained how major developments can create opportunities for students to gain experience across wider supply chains, with placements tailored to their individual interests and abilities.

She said: “The placements that have worked particularly well for us have come from long-term relationships.

“It’s about making contact early, getting to know the individual and being flexible enough to make the experience work for them.

“On the gigafactory project, we’ve been able to involve our wider supply chain, giving students opportunities to explore different roles and parts of the industry they might never have considered.”

However, as Jane Thompson, associate principal for external funding and business development at Education Partnership North East, emphasised, successful collaboration also depends on clear expectations, with colleges preparing students for work and employers providing constructive feedback.

She said: “We need employers to tell us when learners aren’t ready for the workplace, so we can understand what’s missing and improve how we prepare them.

“But, equally, we need to help businesses understand the value of offering placements and apprenticeships, not just for young people but for their own future workforce too.

“It’s about building stronger relationships, understanding what employers need and ensuring placements provide a genuine pathway into apprenticeships and employment, rather than simply meeting a target.”

That need for collaboration also raised questions about making placements more manageable for employers without compromising students’ experiences.

Kirsty Tewkesbury, planning and enabling manager at Homes England, described an approach adopted by a consultancy working on one of the agency’s projects, where students spent individual days with specialist sub-consultants, experiencing different disciplines while sharing the responsibility for supervision.

She said: “We had consultants who found taking a student for a full week difficult, but one day was much more manageable.

“The students spent time with different disciplines, including planning, highways, geotechnical engineering and cost management.

“It gave them a much broader understanding of the opportunities available while reducing the commitment required from each employer.

“It’s a model we’d like to promote more widely.”

Drawing these themes together, Alex Whelan, skills project manager at the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority, argued that lasting progress depended on turning successful partnerships into a consistent regional approach.

He added: “We need to move away from ad hoc approaches and build long-term relationships between employers and education providers.

“That gives businesses the opportunity to help shape the curriculum, identify talent and develop placements that genuinely work.

“We also need a consistent standard of work-readiness, so employers can have confidence the young people coming into their workplaces are properly prepared.

“There’s a real opportunity for CTEC, education providers, employers and regional organisations to work collectively to bring that together and establish a more coordinated approach across the region.”

What role can procurement, social value and regional collaboration play in scaling up industry placements?

From North East mayor Kim McGuinness’ Plan for Homes, which aims to deliver more than 15,000 social and affordable homes over the next decade, to multi-million-pound regeneration schemes, regional investment presents opportunities to create jobs, develop skills and deliver wider social value.

The Construction Industry Placement Scheme, for example, forms part of the North East Mayoral Strategic Authority’s £18 million Construction Skills Package, which acts as a key component of its wider £250 million North East Skills Programme.

The scheme aims to increase industry placements for learners, helping to bridge the gap between education and employment while building the skilled workforce needed to deliver the region’s housing, regeneration and infrastructure ambitions.

Yet differing client expectations, inconsistent procurement requirements and poor coordination can make those commitments difficult to translate into meaningful opportunities.

Discussion turned to whether a more consistent regional approach, involving contracting authorities, employers and their supply chains, could turn existing obligations into a sustainable pipeline of placements.

For Tom Lamb, chief strategy officer at Sunderland-headquartered social housing regeneration firm RE:GEN Group, the value of work experience is personal, having started his career through a two-week placement.

He argued contractors’ existing procurement and social value commitments could achieve more if aligned with regional workforce needs and future projects.

Tom said: “We’ve got a number of commitments and pledges already built into our contracts and the social value we deliver.

“The opportunity is to look at those more strategically, understand the pipeline of work and connect that with workforce demand.

“Once we know what’s needed, we can make it easier for tier one contractors and their supply chains to deliver those commitments.

“At the moment, there are multiple requests coming from different directions, and across such a fragmented industry, opportunities can get lost.”

Kirsty suggested contracting authorities could establish clearer expectations across large-scale developments.

She added: “We need to understand what role each organisation can play and how we can use our funding programmes and relationships with tier one contractors to support this.

“There’s an opportunity to align our strategic objectives, build placement targets into funding and major projects, and make sure those commitments flow through the supply chain.”

Sunderland City Council’s extensive regeneration programme provided a practical example of how public investment can stimulate construction activity and create opportunities for skills development.

Alan Smith, the council’s commercial manager, highlighted the multi-million-pound Riverside Sunderland masterplan and its investment in HICSA, while stressing social value expectations must reflect the nature and duration of individual contracts.

He said: “We try to be realistic about what can be achieved through procurement.

“If you’ve got a 16-week refurbishment contract, you’re not going to create ten apprenticeships from it.

“We need to match social value requirements to individual projects and make sure the commitments are proportionate and achievable.

“But we also need to look at the bigger picture.

“The council has invested heavily in regenerating Sunderland, and HICSA is a great example of how we can work with education providers to develop the skills needed to support that investment.”

“Social value is part of a competitive tender process, and we’re all making different commitments behind closed doors – why not bring buyers and contractors together, agree a minimum requirement based on the type, value and location of each project, and make a standard everyone works towards?”
Darush Dodds, director of corporate affairs and social value, Esh Group

For Darush, who has co-chaired the North East Chamber of Commerce working group behind its recently-published social value guide, the answer lies in changing how social value is assessed during procurement.

He proposed a common regional minimum standard, agreed by contracting authorities and employers, to remove competition over placement numbers during tendering.

Darush said: “At the moment, social value is part of a competitive tender process, and we’re all making different commitments behind closed doors.

“One contractor might promise eight placements, another ten and another 12, without necessarily considering what is actually needed.

“Why not bring the buyers and contractors together, agree a minimum requirement based on the type, value and location of each project, and make a standard everyone works towards?

“It takes the competition out of social value and gives businesses the confidence to invest in the people, training and resources needed to deliver.”

However, a common regional standard would also need to account for smaller businesses, many of which lack the capacity of larger contractors – a concern reinforced by Catriona, who stressed any solution must extend beyond the biggest employers.

She added: “We need to bring in businesses that aren’t currently engaged, particularly the smaller companies that simply don’t have the capacity to take students on.

“Procurement can help, but it isn’t going to be the complete answer.

“We’ve got to work together across the region, understand what support those businesses need and make sure the opportunities reach beyond the major contractors.”

What practical actions are needed to achieve the 1677 target and build a sustainable construction skills pipeline?

With the opportunities and obstacles laid bare, attention turned to making meaningful industry placements easier to secure, organise and deliver.

Achieving the 1677 target would require better coordination between colleges and employers, greater visibility of placement opportunities and more strategic workforce planning.

A regional system matching learners with employers emerged as a priority, with Rachel highlighting the potential for housing providers to offer opportunities throughout the year.

She pointed to believe housing’s maintenance operation, which carries out about 70,000 repairs and 24,500 safety inspections annually, providing a steady stream of practical work less dependent on individual construction projects.

Rachel said: “We need to map demand against construction activity, so employers can see where placements are needed, in which disciplines and at what time.

“If that information was available regionwide, businesses could identify opportunities that fit their operations, rather than responding to individual requests.

“There’s a real opportunity with housing providers because repairs and maintenance work is constant.

“It’s experience that is already there, ready to be tapped into.”

Turning that visibility into placements would require dedicated support to connect businesses with colleges and remove practical barriers facing learners.

Jane highlighted CTEC’s role in bringing the two together, alongside measures to help students access placements.

She added: “We’ve appointed someone specifically to work with businesses and help bridge that gap.

“We can also support students with travel, which is important because many are under 18 and placements may be difficult to reach.

“But the scale is enormous.

“We’re talking about more than 25,000 days of experience, and we need to find ways of working together to make that achievable.”

While those measures could help meet the immediate target, Susan argued lasting progress depended on aligning education with the industry’s changing skills requirements.

She said: “We need a more demand-led education system, where colleges and universities have greater certainty about the skills employers will need.

“That means understanding what the industry requires from the curriculum and preparing learners with skills they can transfer across different roles.

“We can’t keep educating people in separate silos.

“We need to give them the knowledge and confidence to take advantage of opportunities throughout the built environment.”

Greater certainty over future construction activity would be equally important for employers.
Tom pointed to RE:GEN’s involvement in Gentogether, a £170 million, ten-year modernisation and procurement partnership with Sunderland-based housing provider Gentoo Group, as an example of how long-term work can underpin skills planning.

He added: “We know we’ll still be delivering kitchens and bathrooms in Sunderland in nine years’ time.

“That gives us the opportunity to understand our commitments, identify where the skills gaps are and work with colleges to address them.

“It’s about joining everything together, so we’re planning for the workforce we’ll need, rather than reacting when the demand arrives.”

Rebecca brought the discussion to a close with a rallying cry to look beyond the 1677 target.

With an ageing workforce adding urgency to the challenge, she stressed true success would ultimately be measured in helping more young people turn their training into lasting careers in construction.

She added: “We need to make sure young people are equipped with the skills employers need, understand the full range of careers available to them and have every opportunity to build a future in the industry.

“This is potentially one of the biggest opportunities further education and the construction sector have had in a long time.

“We owe it to these young people to do everything we can to get this right.

“We might not get another opportunity like this again.”

November 16, 2026

  • Events
  • Feature
  • Roundtable

Created by Peter Anderson